A franchise notice of default, explained

What a notice of default is, what the sources say it should contain, which contract clauses it rests on, and why some state statutes also require written reasons.

A franchise notice of default is a written communication from the franchisor saying that the franchisee is in breach of the franchise agreement. It often sets a date by which the problem must be fixed, and says that termination may follow if it is not. We could not find a statute or court opinion that defines "notice of default" for franchising in general. The term is a creature of the contract, so the definition that matters is the one in your own agreement.

What a notice is supposed to contain

The best published description we found is in an article on the International Franchise Association website, "Handling Defaults and Terminations Effectively," written in 2019 by two private lawyers from the franchisor-practice side. It is their view, not a rule of law. They say a default notice should cite the franchise agreement section, list the facts, and "specify exactly what is required for a cure." They add that "the notice must provide the appropriate cure period, whether dictated by the franchise agreement or by state statute."

On incurable defaults, the same article says the franchisor must first decide whether a default can be cured at all, and that "If the default is non-curable, the notice should explicitly state that fact." So a notice can be read for four things: the clause, the facts, the cure required and the period given. If any is missing, that is a point a lawyer licensed in your state can look at against the agreement and the statute.

  • The section of the franchise agreement said to be breached
  • The facts the franchisor relies on
  • What would count as a cure, if the default is curable
  • The cure period, or a statement that the default cannot be cured

The contract clauses behind a notice

Franchise agreements typically address default in a few places. A set of IFA webinar slides lists the provisions that govern a default: the basis for default, the cure period, the effective date, and the notice requirements, including the delivery method, address and timing, with examples such as "Hand Delivery/Courier, Certified Mail, Email, etc." A notice that misses the agreement's delivery method is something to raise with a lawyer, not something to assume either way.

You do not have to guess where those clauses sit. Item 17 of the Franchise Disclosure Document is a table that, under 16 CFR 436.5(q), has separate rows for termination by the franchisor without cause, termination with cause, "cause" defined for curable defaults, "cause" defined for non-curable defaults, and the franchisee's obligations on termination or non-renewal. It points to the matching section of the agreement. The rule's own lead-in tells readers: "You should read these provisions in the agreements attached to this disclosure document." The guide to Item 17 of the FDD walks through the rows.

Two further contract mechanisms appear in the sources. First, a repeated default clause: the IFA-hosted article says franchisees want to avoid accumulating default notices because repeated violations can later support an incurable default. Second, a defined-default clause. In Dunkin' Donuts Franchising LLC v. C3WAIN Inc., an unpublished 2017 Third Circuit decision, the agreement said a franchisee would be "in default" if its owners committed a fraud on the franchisor relating to a franchised business, and gave the franchisor "the right to terminate the entire franchise agreement." That example shows how a contract can define a default, not that any particular clause is enforceable in your state. See incurable defaults and cross-default and repeated default.

Where state law adds requirements

Some states require the notice itself to meet statutory standards. Minnesota's statute says the notice must set out "all the reasons for the termination or cancellation" and be given at least 90 days in advance, with 60 days from receipt to correct the reasons stated. Washington's statute says good cause includes a failure to cure "after being given written notice thereof and a reasonable opportunity, which in no event need be more than thirty days." The New Jersey statute, read from a mirror of the official text, requires "written notice setting forth all the reasons" at least 60 days in advance, with shorter periods for specific grounds. Wisconsin's statute, also read from a mirror, requires at least 90 days' written notice that states all reasons and gives the dealer 60 days to rectify; if the deficiency is rectified within 60 days, "the notice shall be void."

In the Third Circuit case above, the court held that the New Jersey written-notice requirement was met because the termination letter set out the clause that had been breached and the facts. The opinion is unpublished and the part we read does not discuss a cure period, so it is only an example of how one court read one letter under one state's law.

The statutes also make exceptions. Several allow termination without a cure period for listed events such as bankruptcy, abandonment or a related criminal conviction. Washington's statute lists those four categories; Minnesota's has its own list, including a 24-hour cure notice for one kind of default that harms the franchisor's goodwill. Whether any exception fits your facts is for a lawyer to say. For state-by-state figures see state franchise relationship laws.

What a notice of default is not

A default notice is not a termination notice, although some documents combine the two. It is also not a court order. Under the FTC's own account, the Franchise Rule is a disclosure rule that does not regulate the substance of the relationship terms, and franchise relationship issues are generally governed by the private contract. So the notice draws its force from your agreement and any state statute, not from federal law. The article on whether a franchisor can terminate covers that point, and what to do after a notice of default covers the practical next steps.

If you hold a notice, the check your notice page lists what to look for, and the guide on what a default notice states goes through each element. Your notice and your franchise agreement control your own dates, and a lawyer licensed in your state can advise on them.

Where this came from

Read next

Check your notice